Do you know what’s a “yard sale”? Its when you haul ass like a Dakar god and shit goes horribly wrong. Waking up with your foot next to your helmet and all your possessions once strapped to the back of your bike now lay scattered all over the road.
Luckily there’s some technology that can help rescue you and your bike. Personal trackers have come a long way but there are some caveats.
We wrote the article with the link bellow for SuperBike Magazine South Africa and they were kind to put it up on their website. It is a questions & answers interview we had with GEOS, SPOT, and Garmin. Comparing the devices, the options and pitfalls, choosing one ain’t as obvious as it seems. We hope it is of value. 

Review – SPOT Gen3 vs Garmin Inreach Mini

We have been using both these devices for a a few years. The SPOT was our first one and we raplaced it with the Garmin a year and a bit ago.

SPOT Gen3

  • The spot is a basic tracker and SOS unit. It tracks on intervals that the user can set SPOT Gen3 Personal tracker reviewon 2min, 5min, 10min or other as needed. On the basic plan, only the 10min breadcrumbs are available.
  • The unit makes use of 4AAA Lithium rechargeable batteries. They do last quite a long time even when tracking on 8hour plus riding days. What we did find difficult was to find replacement batteries. Off course you can recharge them but you need to carry a charger just for that purpose. Or alternatively, if you always ride from home on small trips make sure to charge them. We wrote to SPOT to ask if they can’t just build in a small charing system to charge with a USB.
  • Coverage is not as good as the Garmin system, but that said SPOT told me with the interview they are working hard to get the entire globe covered.
  • The SPOT package plans and unit cost are considerably less than the Garmin Inreach.
  • The tracking website to see your crumbs are not as good and user-friendly as the Garmin offers. SPOT said they are working on it.
  • There is no two way messaging on this unit. You can only send pre-set SMS’s to friends or family.

Garmin Inreach Mini

  • The current coverage of the Garmin unit has a bigger footprint over SPOT.
  • Website and smartphone/mobile app work well with the Inreach Mini and there are useful functions to set up and use for the unit.
  • SMS messaging and receiving of SMS messages is available on the Inreach Mini
  • Battery power is not great and charging will have to be done on a daily basis if used 8hours + per day. Garmin does not recommend to just have it plugged in all the time. The battery has to run flat and charged through the cycles. The unit uses a built-in battery good for a few days depending on the tracking.
  • The only real negatives are the once-off subscription fee that SPOT does not have. And the cost of the unit and plans are quite high. On the basic plan for a full day tracking the user are charged per breadcrumb. Those pins can run up the cost quite quick.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *